By my count (i.e. what sbot shows me) we have

• 3 votes for option 1 (Keep ButtCouncil)
• 8 votes for option 2 (Drop the "Butt")

Counting @zelf's post and everyone who liked it as "either 1 or 2", this would become

• 10 votes for option 1 (Keep ButtCouncil)
• 15 votes for option 2 (Drop the "Butt")

with "Handshake Council" being the / a commonly supported name.